中国经济问题 ›› 2026›› Issue (02): 183-.

• • 上一篇    

担保与私人交易——近代在华外商的买办契约选择问题

  

  • 出版日期:2026-03-20 发布日期:2026-06-02

Guarantees and Private Trade: The Comprador Contract Choicesof Foreign Firms in Modern China

  • Online:2026-03-20 Published:2026-06-02

摘要: 本文从买办的担保责任出发,对近代在华外商企业中的买办私人交易现象进行重新审视。基于私人关系在近代中国商业活动中的重要地位,本文认为嵌入本土关系网络的私人交易是买办接受担保责任的重要前提。在此基础上构建的多任务委托代理模型显示,买办私人交易自主权随着特有风险占比提高而提高,反之则下降:当特有风险占主导地位时,风险与激励之间可能出现正向变动关系。对汇丰银行的案例分析为理论分析提供了恰当的经验证据。因此,本文不再认为私人交易是买办制度的根本缺陷,而是外商应对来自华商信用风险的内生选择。

关键词: 买办, 私人交易, 本土关系, 担保

Abstract: This paper re-examines the compradors’ private trade within foreign companies in modern China throughthe lens of the comprador's role as a guarantor. Given the significant role of personal ties in modern Chinese commercialpractice, this paper argues that private trade embedded in local social networks was a crucial prerequisite for compradors toassume guarantee liability. The multitask principal- agent model constructed on this basis reveals that the autonomy olcompradors’ private trade increases with the proportion of idiosyncratic risk and decreases otherwvise; when idiosyncratic riskdominates, a positive correlation between risk and incentives may emerge. A case study of the Hongkong and ShanghaiBanking, Corporation provides appropriate empirical evidence for the theoretical analysis. Consequently, this paper no longeiviews private trade as a fundamental flaw of the comprador system, but rather as an endogenous choice made by foreign mer.chants to mitigate the credit risks associated with Chinese merchants.