中国经济问题 ›› 2026›› Issue (03): 11-.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

何为不平等交换——对国际不平等交换理论的批判性反思

  

  • 出版日期:2026-05-20 发布日期:2026-07-27

What is Unequal Exchange: A Critical Reflection on the Theory of International Unequal Exchange

  • Online:2026-05-20 Published:2026-07-27

摘要: 从第二国际时代开始,马克思主义经济学就开始发展国际不平等交换理论。20世纪60年代,伊曼纽尔发表了《不平等交换》一书,在生产价格理论基础上提出了一个新的不平等交换理论,这一理论以劳动力不能在国际流动为前提,分析了国际生产价格的形成机制以及由此造成的国际价值转移。伊曼纽尔的理论引起了广泛的争论,也催生了一些新的研究。迄今为止,在生产价格基础上研究不平等交换已成为文献中的主流。这些研究虽有重要贡献,但也存在如下弱点:第一,倾向于将不平等交换等同于价值转移,而忽略了对这两者间差异的探讨;第二,仅仅在生产价格的基础上解释不平等交换,没有深入探讨不平等交换与垄断这一现代资本主义经济结构性特征的内在联系。进一步发展不平等交换理论,需要反思何为不平等交换,明确判定不平等交换的标准,以解决上述问题。

关键词: 不平等交换, 伊曼纽尔, 生产价格, 价值转移, 垄断

Abstract: Since the era of the Second International, Marxist economics has been developing the theory of international unequal exchange. In the 1960s, Emmanuel published Unequal Exchange, in which he proposed a novel theory based on the theory of price of production. Premised on the international immobility of labor, his work explored the formation mechanism of international production prices and the resulting international transfer of value. Emmanuel’s theory has sparked extensive debates and given rise to some new research. So far, the study of unequal exchange based on production prices has become the mainstream in the literature. Despite their respective contributions, these theories have the following weaknesses. First, they tend to equate unequal exchange with value transfer, while neglecting the exploration of the differences between them. Second, they interpret unequal exchange merely on the basis of production price, without deeply exploring the intrinsic connection between unequal exchange and monopoly which is a structural feature of modern capitalist economies. Further development of the theory of unequal exchange requires reflection on what unequal exchange is, and a clear definition of the criteria for identifying unequal exchange.

Key words: unequal exchange, Emmanuel, price of production, value transfer, monopoly